Guide review process
After you build your guide in the CMS, your onboarding manager shares your guide with the Bloomberg Connects content team. The content team reviews your guide with the following goals: Ensure that your guide is organized, informative, and easy to use; preserve your organization’s voice for your unique audience; and help your guide meet industry best practices for interpretation, usability, and accessibility.
We encourage you to ask questions and start conversations about any of the feedback we provide. You know your story and your audience best. We’re here to support your creative choices and their integration into the guide.
In This Article
Who is the content team?
The Bloomberg Connects content team is a group of editors with varied backgrounds in content development for the art and cultural sectors. We’re here to support your organization as you develop and refine your guide.
As editors, we have experience working with a range of cultural partners, like botanical gardens, art galleries, hospital collections, public art projects, museums, publications, and foundations.
Our team includes editorial managers (who provide feedback during content review) and copyeditors (who make sure your guide is in near perfect shape).
What is the guide review process?
The Connects content team helps you refine your guide in a few stages:
- Self-serve content checklist (in the CMS)
- Content review
- Copyediting
- Final review
We want to help you move through these stages as smoothly as possible. We approach every guide as a unique case and we aim to be flexible and keep you informed throughout the process.
At every stage, our goal is to help you provide the best experience for your visitors.
Content checklist
Before you begin content review, use the content checklist in the CMS. The checklist helps you make sure your guide meets some basic requirements. You can find the checklist at the top of the CMS navigation bar. For more, see Content checklist.
Content review
After you complete the content checklist, tell your onboarding manager that you’re ready for it to be reviewed. At this point, stop editing your guide so that it can enter content review.
Process
During content review, an editorial manager reviews your guide for the minimum content requirements, narrative structure, user experience, cohesiveness, and overall consistency in format. The editorial manager sends their feedback to your onboarding manager, who passes it on to you. Then, you can make any necessary edits to your content in the CMS. If you have any questions or things to discuss, your onboarding manager can arrange a meeting with your editorial team or relay the questions.
Feedback
The content review considers the needs and questions of a range of visitors—from the returning visitor to a first-time guest. Any encouragement to clarify or contextualize content or organization, resolve technical issues, or address missing information is meant to create welcoming, user-friendly information for all types of visitors.
Example feedback
- Consider moving the permanent exhibition into a section higher up on the home screen. It’s best to feature exhibitions with interpretive content earlier on your guide’s home screen.
- Reconsider titles throughout. There is a lot of repetition between item titles, audio titles, and audio description fields. These should all be different to create varied access points into the content.
- Standardize the use of secondary titles for items in the exhibition. To create a more consistent experience, we recommend including secondary titles for all of the items or none of the items.
There are some things that we don’t comment on. For example:
- We don’t replace subject expertise. We help make your content accessible. We respect the knowledge and specialist insight that you bring to your guide. Our role is to help present that expertise in a way that is clear and engaging for a broad range of visitors, not to challenge curatorial or specialist decisions.
- We don’t require a specific interpretive approach. We support clear communication. How you tell the story, structure the narrative, or draw connections between objects is part of your creative and interpretive approach. We only suggest changes if they improve clarity, accessibility, or the user experience.
- We don’t change content simply for the sake of uniformity. We only recommend changes if they improve usability, accessibility, comprehension, or consistency within your guide. We don't want to make every guide follow the same template.
- We don’t override your organization’s voice. Every organization has its own character, audience, and way of communicating. We don't expect all guides to use a single editorial style. We want to help make sure the content is clear, welcoming, and easy to navigate.
- We don’t edit for stylistic preference. If the wording is clear and purposeful, we won't suggest alternatives simply because we would phrase something differently.
- We don’t remove personality. Distinctive voices, local character, and authentic storytelling make guides richer and more engaging. Our goal is to support those qualities, not smooth them away.
Copyediting
After you make all the edits from your content review, your guide enters copyediting.
A Bloomberg Connects copyeditor edits your guide for grammar, punctuation, spelling, and any editorial issues that were missed during content review.
The copyeditor assigned to your guide makes straightforward changes directly to your content in the CMS. Copyeditors keep a list of questions that need your input. They only correct clear errors.
Your copyeditor uses your style guide to make recommendations.
Copyeditors do the following tasks:
- Lightly edit for grammar and readability.
- Check for consistency. This includes formatting, punctuation, terminology, spelling (for example, US vs. UK English), and other style elements.
- Fact-check as needed. Verify proper nouns, titles, and other references using your website and other reliable sources.
- Improve the visitor experience. Flag issues that may affect readability or functionality in the Bloomberg Connects app.
After copyediting is complete, your onboarding manager lets you know. They might share a list of questions from the copyeditor, if needed.
Final review
After you answer the copyeditor’s questions, your guide enters the final review.
Your editorial manager, the content team manager, and Bloomberg Connects leadership work together on the final review. Each person brings a unique perspective to the review, so we can make sure that all angles are considered.
Final review includes two or three rounds of reviews, depending on the state of your guide. Between rounds, your onboarding manager sends you any outstanding edit requests and questions, combining feedback from multiple people when possible. To launch your guide on time, be attentive during this time and respond to questions quickly.